Episode 32

Should You Buy a Rental Property or an S&P 500 Index Fund

29 min
Should You Buy a Rental Property or an S&P 500 Index Fund

In this episode of The Deal Vault, Greg and Nate try something new with a segment called Real Estate Overreactions, borrowed from the Monday sports radio format, where hot takes get judged as overreactions or not.

Listen Now

Listen to the Episode

Listen on:

Watch the Episode

Full Episode Transcript

In this episode of The Deal Vault, Greg and Nate try something new with a segment called Real Estate Overreactions, borrowed from the Monday sports radio format where hot takes get judged as overreactions or not. They take on the claim that a rental that doesn’t cash flow $500 a month isn’t worth buying, using cash on cash return, the S&P 500 as a benchmark, and the effect of leverage to show why a fixed dollar rule can mislead investors.

From there they move through the idea that lenders pressure appraisers to value low, why buying a turnkey rental isn’t automatically leaving money on the table, and whether pad splits and the death of long term rentals are real trends or just loud opinions. If you invest in rentals and want a clearer way to judge deals, lenders, and strategies, this one is for you.


Who This Episode Is For:

• Rental property investors who feel stuck on a $500 a month cash flow rule
• New investors comparing real estate to stocks and index funds
• Borrowers who worry that lenders pressure appraisers to hit a number
• Busy professionals deciding whether to buy turnkey or do the work themselves
• Investors curious about pad splits, short term rentals, and the future of long term rentals

More Episodes

View All Episodes

Episode 31

Are Comps Your Friend or Your Foe in Real Estate Investing

36 min

In this episode of The Deal Vault, Greg, Nate, and Sarah open with a lighthearted detour into ASMR before asking a question every real estate investor should care about: are comps a friend or a foe?

Episode 30

Why Trust Is the First Thing Investors Look for in a Lending Partner

16 min

In this episode of The Deal Vault, Greg and the LoanBidz team take the podcast on the road to BiggerPockets Conference 2026 in Orlando, their fourth year attending and sponsoring the event. Instead of a typical sit down, they walk the floor and ask real estate investors, including borrowers they’ve worked with, two simple questions.

Episode 29

Why Aimless Relentlessness Can Slow Your Deal Down

34 min

In this episode of The Deal Vault, Greg closes out the podcast's five-part Core Values series by sitting down with Dylan from the LoanBidz team to tackle the final value: Relentless Execution.

Episode 28

What Separates a Service Provider From a True Partner in Business

25 min

In this episode of The Deal Vault, Greg sits down with AJ Exner, LoanBidz's Account Executive Team Lead, to continue their series unpacking the company's five core values, this time landing on Trusted Partner. They trade real stories about spotting dishonesty, from small lies to full blown "peacocking," and what it actually costs to do the right thing when it isn't the most profitable option.

Back to The Deal Vault Podcast